Currency is part of your return
Why the same share can earn two different returns, and how to read both without confusing them.
Key takeaways
- A foreign investment has two returns: the asset's own, and the one you receive at home.
- The difference between them is the move in the exchange rate over the same dates.
- Compare assets in one currency, over the same dates, before drawing conclusions.
When an Indian investor owns a share listed in New York, two things move at once: the share price in dollars, and the value of the dollar in rupees. Your experience is the combination of the two. Keeping them apart in your head is the first step to reading foreign returns correctly.
Two returns, both correct
The local-currency return answers the question, “How did this business's shares do?” It is the number quoted in the company's home market and the right one for judging the business.
The home-currency return answers a different question: “How did this do for me?” It includes the change in the exchange rate between the day you bought and the day you measure. If the rupee weakened against the dollar over that period, your rupee return is higher than the dollar return. If the rupee strengthened, it is lower.
Why it matters for decisions
- Judging a business: use the local-currency return, so currency moves do not flatter or punish the company.
- Judging your portfolio: use your home-currency return, because that is what you can actually spend.
- Comparing two assets: put both in the same currency and the same dates, or the comparison means little.
A common mistake is to compare a foreign share's dollar return with an Indian share's rupee return and conclude one did better. They are measured in different units. Convert one, or both, to the same currency over the same sessions, then compare.
Can you remove currency risk?
Some funds hedge currency, aiming to deliver roughly the local return without the exchange-rate effect. Hedging has costs and is not always available to individual investors. For long-term investors, many simply accept currency movement as part of owning foreign assets and keep it in mind when reviewing results.
How INRGIFT shows it
Wherever a return crosses currencies, INRGIFT labels which currency it is in and measures everything over the same dates. In Compare you can switch the base currency and see how much of a difference the exchange rate made over the period you chose.
Ask two questions of every foreign return: how did the asset do, and how did it do for me?
This article is for research and education only. It is not investment, tax or legal advice, and INRGIFT is not a broker or an investment adviser. Rules and limits change; check the current position with your bank or a qualified adviser before acting. See our risk disclosure.